The Studies

Contents

This is a timeline representing all the studies carried out over more than 40 years

echelleetudes
  • In green, the independent studies by recognized experts, with the exception of study 1979A, requested by the Minister himself.
  • In red, the dissuasive studies prepared by or under the authority of senior officials of the Québec Ministry of Transport and its division, the Société des Traversiers du Québec.

The methods used to bias the information are described in the “findings and comments” column of the interactive table below.

For a quick overview, view or print this document summarizing the MTQ’s past interventions.

Key information for using the interactive table effectively

Map of the proposed alignments (Appendix E4)
Map of alignments P1 to P6 – Appendix E4 of the 1999 study

To better understand the studies, it is important to visualize the 2 main sites proposed for building a bridge, P1 and P4.

  • P1 (map of the alignments, Appendix E4; see also the map above): the bridge upstream of the Hydro-Québec power lines, at the place known as La Boule, was determined to be the optimal site as early as 1979 by the engineering firm LGL of Montréal and engineers from New York. See study 1979-A, commissioned directly by the Minister of Transport of the day, Mr. Lucien Lessard.
  • P4 (map, Appendix E4; see also the map above): the bridge alignment presented in the secret study 1979-B near the ferries.

The other routes P2, P3, P5 and P6 were not retained (map of the alignments, Appendix E4; see also the map above). A route in the estuary was discussed in the 1973, 1974 and 1976 studies. However, as the alignment passed through the middle of the village of Tadoussac, it was not retained.

The Interactive Table of Studies

History of the studies for a bridge project at the mouth of the Saguenay at Tadoussac

At a glance: 50 years of estimates, in 2025 dollars

Converted to 2025 dollars with Canada’s consumer price index (CPI), all estimates published from 1973 to 2015 lie between $276 million and $1.8 billion for the complete project (bridge and approach roads). At the La Boule site (P1), the 1979, 1995, 1998 and 2015 estimates stay between $479 and $584 million. The $4.2 billion figure put forward in 2025, with no published study, is more than six times the 1999 estimate at the same ferry site (P4).

StudySite (alignment)Complete project ($M, 2025)% of $4.2B
1973Estuary (P5)3498%
1974Estuary (P5)3458%
1976Estuary (P5)2767%
1979ALa Boule (P1)56213%
1995La Boule (P1)54513%
1998La Boule (P1)47911%
1999La Boule (P1)1,264*30%
1999Ferries (P4)65916%
2009La Boule (P1)1,816*43%
2009Ferries (P4)1,291*31%
2015La Boule (P1)58414%
2025Ferries (P4)4,200100%

* The three historical estimates above $1 billion reflect particular design choices: 1999 P1, more than 6 km of highway tunnels (3 tunnels, 6.3 km); 2009 P1, 11 viaducts totalling almost 5 km; 2009 P4, a bridge with a 2.1% grade rising up to 142 m above the water.

Method: amount in the price year × 2025 CPI ÷ CPI of that year (Statistics Canada, 2002 = 100; 2025 = 164.2). The CPI corrects for general inflation, not for bridge-specific construction costs; alignments and approaches differ from one study to another. Details and sources in the table below. Compiled by Pierre Breton.

Interactive table – sort by column and search

Click a column header to sort, or use the search field to filter. On small screens the table scrolls horizontally. The table content is in French. Amounts in 2025 dollars are converted from the 2015 values using the Canadian Consumer Price Index (Statistics Canada, annual average: 2015 = 126.6; 2025 = 164.2; factor 1.297).

Historique des études de projet de pont à l’embouchure du Saguenay à Tadoussac
AnnéeÉtudes / Constats, commentaires et études complètesExtraitsAuteursCommandé parHauteur du tablierTracé & portée centrale
Carte des tracés : annexe E4
(voir aussi la carte ci-haut)
Coût pont proposé origine/2025 (IPC Canada)Coût des routes d’approchesTotal projet en $ (2025)
2025Bonification de l’étude d’opportunité sur la construction d’un pont à TadoussacÀ suivre, lors de la publication de l’étudeGroupe Pont Estuaire/Fjord du Saguenay (SYSTRA, CIMA+, WSP)MTMDQ (Transports Québec)110mPrès des traversiers (tracé P4)
1350m
Inconnu (étude non publiée)Inconnu4200M$
P4
2016Traversiers (Implantation d’un duc-d’Albe au quai de Tadoussac)K1 à K84Roche Itée, Groupe conseil et Société des Traversiers du QcSTQn/an/an/an/aNon calculé
2015 (tracé P1) Projet optimalÉtude d’un projet de pont à La Boule : Confirmation de faisabilitéG1àG45 – G46àG50 – G51à56P. Brisset et COWI International Ing. Danemark-CanadaSociété du Pont sur le Saguenay75mBOU (tracé P1)
1150m
275M$ (2015)
357M$ (2025)
(pont seulement)
175M$ (2015)
227M$ (2025)
584M$
P1
2009 (tracé P1)idemidemidemidem150m pente 1%BOU (tracé P1)
1350m
712M$ (2004)
1120M$ (2025)
(pont seulement)
454M$(2005)
700M$ (2025)
1816M$
P1
2009 (tracé P4)Étude d’impact sur le projet d’un pont sur la riv. Saguenay(version finale)F1àF29 – F37 – F41àF85Consortium SNC-Lavalin/Génivar (durée: 8 ans) et MTQGuy Chevrette Min. des Transports140m S
112m N
pente 2.1%
TRA (tracé P4)
1350m
712M$ (2004)
1120M$ (2025)
(pont seulement)
103M
(2004)
162M$ (2025)
1291M$
P4
1999 (tracé P1)idemidemidemidem88mBOU (tracé P1)
1150m
174M$ (1999)
307M$ (2025)
(pont seulement)
Annexe E5 : l’étude indiquait par erreur 234M$, chiffre qui s’appliquait au tracé P3
540M$(1999)
957M$ (2025)
(dont 3 tunnels totalisant 6,3 km : 483M$ (1999), soit 854M$ (2025))
1264M$
P1
1999 (tracé P4)Étude d’opportunité Traversée Riv. Saguenay B.Ste-Catherine-TadoussacE1 à E49 (+E18B)Consortium Naturam- Génivar et Buckland&Taylor/COWI Vancouver et MTQJacques Brassard, Min. des transports 88mTRA (tracé P4)
1420m
252M$(1999) 445M$ (2025)
(pont seulement)
119M$(1999) 211M$ (2025)659M$
P4
1998Projet de pont par L-G Coulombe,ing.Transport Québec L1 à L3Louis-Georges Coulombe, ingénieur,
MTQ
MTQ interne75mBOU (tracé P1 ; tracé D de LGL-79)218M (1998)
394M$ (2025)
47M$(1998)
84M$ (2025)
479M$
P1
1995Évolution de la circulation traverse Tadoussac-B.Ste-Cat.D1 à D6Pierre Lord
Ing. MTQ. Mise à jour coûts LGL1979A
MTQ interneidem LGL 79BOU (tracé P1)
Mise à jour des prix seuls
245M$(1995)
460M$ (2025)
(pont seulement)
45M$(1995)
84M$ (2025)
545M$
P1
1986 (tracé P1)Exposé de projet de pont sur la rivière SaguenayC1 à C12P.Brisset, Arch. Boulva & Ass.Ing. BCPT & Ass.Ing. N/D70mBOU (tracé P1)
1150m
N/DN/Dnon calculé
1979B (tracé P4)Évaluation globale d’un projet de pont sur la rivière SaguenayB1 à B10M-C Levesque Urbaniste (MTQ)MTQ interneN/DTRA (tracé P4)
1200m(erreur)
1300m(réel)
N/DN/Dnon calculé
1979A (tracé P1)Lien à travers la rivière Saguenay / reliant B-Ste-Cat. à TadoussacA1 à A14Lalonde, Girouard, Letendre Ass. ing., Montreal / Steinman, Boyton ass. Ing. New-York
Lucien lessard, Ministre des transport 76-79140mBOU (tracé P1)
1150m
115M$ (1979)
477M$ (2025)
(Pont seulement)
20.5M$ *(1979)
84M$ (2025)
562M$
P1
1976Cost-Benefit Analysis of a bridge at TadoussacJ1 à J9T.A. Monti . McGill UniversityThese de maîtriseidemEstuaire (tracé P5)
1158m
52.5M$(1976)
276M$ (2025)
(Coût total du projet)
Inclus dans le coût du pont276M$
P5
1974Commentaire sur une étude préliminaire de rentabilité d’un projet de pont projeté sur la rivière Saguenay entre Baie-Ste Catherine et Tadoussac I1 à I4Rapport du service des affaires extra-ministérielles par Charles Hamelin ing.MTQ interneidemEstuaire (tracé P5)
1158m
55M$ (1974)
345M$ (2025)
(Coût total du projet)
Inclus dans le coût du pont345M$
P5
1973Pont de Tadoussac, étude technique et économiqueH1 à H9Letendre Monti, Gagnon, Nadon ing. Montreal; Freeman, Fox and Partners, Ing. LondresN/D46mEstuaire (tracé P5)
1158m
50M$ (1973)
349M$ (2025)
(Coût total du projet : pont et routes d’approche)
Inclus dans le coût du pont349M$
P5

Is the bridge profitable? Do the math yourself. Our interactive calculator takes the official figures of the 2009 study (table F.14) and lets you choose the discount rate: at 5%, the bridge loses $89M; at 4%, it gains $21M; at 3.3%, the rate used for the Samuel De Champlain Bridge in Montréal, $125M; at 2.7%, the ministry’s current rate, $236M.

The studies one by one

Independent study independent studies by recognized experts (and study 1979A requested by the Minister)   MTQ / STQ studies prepared by or under the authority of the Québec Ministry of Transport and the Société des Traversiers du Québec

1973 Independent study

Tadoussac Bridge, technical and economic study

AuthorsLetendre Monti, Gagnon, Nadon eng., Montréal; Freeman, Fox and Partners, eng., London
Commissioned byN/D
Deck height46m
Alignment & main spanEstuary (alignment P5)
1,158 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$50M (1973)
$349M (2025)
(Total project cost: bridge and approach roads)
Cost of approach roadsIncluded in the bridge cost
ExcerptsH1 to H9
Total project in $ (2025)349M$

1974 MTQ / STQ

Comments on a preliminary profitability study of a proposed bridge project over the Saguenay River between Baie-Sainte-Catherine and Tadoussac

AuthorsReport of the Extra-Ministerial Affairs Service by Charles Hamelin, eng.
Commissioned byMTQ internal
Deck heightsame
Alignment & main spanEstuary (alignment P5)
1,158 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$55M (1974)
$345M (2025)
(Total project cost)
Cost of approach roadsIncluded in the bridge cost
ExcerptsI1 to I4
Total project in $ (2025)345M$

1976 Independent study

Cost-Benefit Analysis of a bridge at Tadoussac

AuthorsT.A. Monti, McGill University
Commissioned byMaster’s thesis
Deck heightsame
Alignment & main spanEstuary (alignment P5)
1,158 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$52.5M (1976)
$276M (2025)
(Total project cost)
Cost of approach roadsIncluded in the bridge cost
ExcerptsJ1 to J9
Total project in $ (2025)276M$

1979A (alignment P1) Independent study

Link across the Saguenay River / connecting Baie-Ste-Catherine to Tadoussac

AuthorsLalonde, Girouard, Letendre Ass. eng., Montréal / Steinman, Boynton Ass. eng., New York
Commissioned byLucien Lessard, Minister of Transport 76-79
Deck height140m
Alignment & main spanBOU (alignment P1)
1,150 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$115M (1979)
$477M (2025)
(Bridge only)
Cost of approach roads20.5M$ *(1979)
84M$ (2025)
ExcerptsA1 to A14
Total project in $ (2025)562M$

1979B (alignment P4) MTQ / STQ

Overall assessment of a bridge project over the Saguenay River

AuthorsM-C Lévesque, urban planner (MTQ)
Commissioned byMTQ internal
Deck heightN/D
Alignment & main spanTRA (alignment P4)
1,200 m (error)
1,300 m (actual)
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)N/D
Cost of approach roadsN/D
ExcerptsB1 to B10
Total project in $ (2025)not calculated

1986 (alignment P1) Independent study

Presentation of a bridge project over the Saguenay River

AuthorsP. Brisset, Arch.; Boulva & Ass. eng.; BCPT & Ass. eng.
Commissioned byN/D
Deck height70m
Alignment & main spanBOU (alignment P1)
1,150 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)N/D
Cost of approach roadsN/D
ExcerptsC1 to C12
Total project in $ (2025)not calculated

1995 MTQ / STQ

Traffic evolution, Tadoussac–Baie-Ste-Catherine crossing

AuthorsPierre Lord
eng., MTQ. Update of LGL 1979A costs
Commissioned byMTQ internal
Deck heightsame as LGL 79
Alignment & main spanBOU (alignment P1)
Price update only
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$245M (1995)
$460M (2025)
(bridge only)
Cost of approach roads45M$(1995)
84M$(2025)
ExcerptsD1 to D6
Total project in $ (2025)545M$

1998 MTQ / STQ

Bridge project by L-G Coulombe, eng., Transport Québec

AuthorsLouis-Georges Coulombe, engineer,
MTQ
Commissioned byMTQ internal
Deck height75m
Alignment & main spanBOU (alignment P1; alignment D of LGL-79)
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)218M (1998)
394M$(2025)
Cost of approach roads47M$(1998)
84M$(2025)
ExcerptsL1 to L3
Total project in $ (2025)479M$

1999 (alignment P4) MTQ / STQ

Opportunity study, Saguenay River crossing, Baie-Ste-Catherine–Tadoussac

AuthorsNaturam-Génivar consortium and Buckland & Taylor/COWI Vancouver and MTQ
Commissioned byJacques Brassard, Minister of Transport
Deck height88m
Alignment & main spanTRA (alignment P4)
1,420 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$252M (1999) $445M (2025)
(bridge only)
Cost of approach roads119M$(1999) 211M$(2025)
ExcerptsE1 to E49 (+E18B)
Total project in $ (2025)659M$

1999 (alignment P1) MTQ / STQ

same

Authorssame
Commissioned bysame
Deck height88m
Alignment & main spanBOU (alignment P1)
1,150 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$174M (1999)
$307M (2025)
(bridge only)
Appendix E5: the study mistakenly indicated $234M, the figure that applied to alignment P3
Cost of approach roads540M$(1999) 957M$(2025)
(including 3 tunnels totalling 6.3 km: $483M (1999), i.e. $854M (2025))
Excerptssame
Total project in $ (2025)1 264M$

2009 (alignment P4) MTQ / STQ

Impact study on the project for a bridge over the Saguenay River (final version)

AuthorsSNC-Lavalin/Génivar consortium (duration: 8 years) and MTQ
Commissioned byGuy Chevrette, Minister of Transport
Deck height140 m S
112 m N
2.1% slope
Alignment & main spanTRA (alignment P4)
1,350 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$712M (2004)
$1,120M (2025)
(bridge only)
Cost of approach roads103M
(2004)
162M$
(2025)
ExcerptsF1 to F29 – F37 – F41 to F85
Total project in $ (2025)1 291M$

2009 (alignment P1) MTQ / STQ

same

Authorssame
Commissioned bysame
Deck height150 m, 1% slope
Alignment & main spanBOU (alignment P1)
1,350 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$712M (2004)
$1,120M (2025)
(bridge only)
Cost of approach roads454M$(2005)
700M$(2025)
Excerptssame
Total project in $ (2025)1 816M$

2015 (alignment P1) Optimal project Independent study

Study of a bridge project at La Boule: confirmation of feasibility

AuthorsP. Brisset and COWI International eng., Denmark-Canada
Commissioned bySociété du Pont sur le Saguenay
Deck height75m
Alignment & main spanBOU (alignment P1)
1,150 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)$275M (2015)
$357M (2025)
(bridge only)
Cost of approach roads175M$ (2015)
$227M (2025)
ExcerptsG1 to G45 – G46 to G50 – G51 to 56
Total project in $ (2025)584M$

2016 MTQ / STQ

Ferries (Installation of a mooring dolphin at the Tadoussac wharf)

AuthorsRoche Ltd, Consulting Group, and Société des Traversiers du Québec
Commissioned bySTQ
Deck heightn/a
Alignment & main spann/a
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)n/a
Cost of approach roadsn/a
ExcerptsK1 to K84
Total project in $ (2025)Not calculated

2025 (alignment P4) MTQ / STQ

Enhancement of the opportunity study on the construction of a bridge at Tadoussac

AuthorsGroupe Pont Estuaire/Fjord du Saguenay (SYSTRA, CIMA+, WSP)
Commissioned byQuébec Ministry of Transport and Sustainable Mobility (MTMDQ)
Deck height110 m
Alignment & main spanNear the ferries (alignment P4)
1,350 m
Proposed bridge cost, original/2025 (Canada CPI)Unknown (study not published)
Cost of approach roadsUnknown
ExtractsTo follow, once the study is published
Total project in $ (2025)$4,200M

Here, then, are four syntheses of the studies according to the proposed costs

Comparison of the proposed costs in constant 2025 dollars, adjusted according to the Bank of Canada formula for calculating Canada’s Consumer Price Index.

Road projects to the optimal site of La Boule (P1)

YearPriceDescription
1979A84M$31 km, 2 lanes + 3rd lane uphill (to be confirmed by the MTQ) (A13, D3, D4)
1986N/DThe study dealt with bridges only
199584M$31 km, update by the MTQ of the price of the road proposed in study 1979A
1999957M$22 km, 4-lane highway, 6.5 km of 4-lane highway tunnels (3 tunnels) and 1.6 km of highway viaducts (275 m, 500 m, 300 m, 500 m) (E7, E5)
2009700M$22 km, 4-lane highway, 5.5 km of highway viaducts (F41 to F47: documents transmitted by an MTQ engineer but not validated by an engineer of the SNC-Lavalin/Génivar consortium)
2015227M$20 km, 2-lane road with 3rd lane uphill, suited to a 2-lane national highway such as Route 138 on the approaches to the Saguenay, one 600 m tunnel ( G12 to G18, G26 (map), G40, G41)

Observations

Route 138 is a 2-lane national highway. A 4-lane road to La Boule increases costs and appears unjustified — all the more so since this road is located in mountainous terrain peaking at about 240 metres.

In the 1999 study, adding 3 highway tunnels (4 lanes) totalling 6.3 km at a cost of $483M (1999), i.e. $854M (2025), seems unjustified, especially since the 1979, 1995 and 2009 projects make no mention of any tunnel and the 2015 project provides for a single 2-lane tunnel of 600 metres under the La Boule mountain at the north exit of the bridge.

In the 2009 study, 5.45 km of highway viaducts are added to the road and all tunnels are eliminated on a road alignment almost identical to that proposed in 1999. There would thus be 12 viaducts, the 3 largest of which would be 980 m, 950 m and 1,400 m. These highway viaducts seem unjustified.

Finally, in the 2015 study, a single 2-lane tunnel of 600 metres is required under the mountain, as well as a few culverts and a few 3-lane viaducts not exceeding 200 metres each.

The choices presented indicate that the 1999 and 2009 studies present high prices compared to the other assessments.

Suspension bridge projects at the optimal site of La Boule (P1)

YearPriceStudy carried out by
1979A477M$LGL engineers, Montréal, and SBGB engineers, New York
1986300M$P. Brisset, architect, with BCPTA eng. and F. Boulva eng., Montréal
1998394M$Québec Ministry of Transport, L-G Coulombe, eng.
1999415M$Alignment P3 confused with P1, Naturam-Génivar consortium and MTQ
1999 corrected306M$Error corrected by the SPS (Société du Pont sur le Saguenay).
2009860M$
SNC-Lavalin/Génivar consortium
2015357M$Société du Pont sur le Saguenay and COWI Int’l

Road projects to the alignment near the ferries (P4)

YearPriceDescription
1979BN/DThe falsified map could hardly be processed by engineers
1999211M$1.2 km tunnel, 950-metre viaduct. Bypass road around the villages of Baie-Ste-Catherine and Tadoussac, an additional 6.3 km (E15)
2009165M$900-metre viaduct; bypass roads with viaduct total 7.8 km for the retained scenarios S1 and N1. (See Impact Study; Technical Feasibility, pages 3.4 and 3.5)

Suspension bridge projects at the site upstream of the ferries (P4)

YearPriceCarried out byDescription
1979BN/DN/DThe falsified map could hardly be processed by the engineers
1999445M$Naturam-Génivar consortium and B&T COWI eng.Deck 88 m high, 1,420 m main span, 1,760 m total span
20091120M$SNC-Lavalin/Génivar consortium and Parsons Brinckerhoff eng.Deck on a 2.1% slope, 140 m high on the south shore and 112 m on the north shore, 1,350 m main span and 2,010 m total span

Observation

At the request of the MTQ, which wished to do away with the tunnel, the consortium in 2009 proposed a bridge whose deck height contradicted the recommendation of the COWI engineers in 1999 (E13). The idea was to lower the height of this deck from 88 metres to a more normal level (±70 m), considering the needs of international navigation. This would have made it possible to reduce the costs of the bridge proposed in 1999.

The SNC-Lavalin/Génivar consortium would instead raise the deck to 140 metres above the water, thus generating a pharaonic project. This result is in line with an MTQ tendency to inflate the price of unwanted projects; see appendices (F57 to F63).

Here is the interactive table of studies for a bridge at the mouth of the Saguenay

By clicking on the name of the study or in the “Analysis and Findings” column, you will have access to our review of the study of interest to you. In addition, we provide a few key excerpts from each study in the “Excerpts” column. A complete .pdf document of each study can be found at the end of each study review as well as in the interactive table.

See the map of alignments P1 to P5

An overview of the existing studies

The Tadoussac bridge project began several decades ago. The Société du Pont has identified several studies carried out on this subject. After analysis, it presented in the 2015 study an update of the earlier studies at the optimal site of La Boule, upstream of the Hydro-Québec lines. These studies had already been updated by the MTQ in 1995, 1999 and 2009; however, numerous biases prevented the start of construction. World experts in the construction of long suspension bridges, familiar with the new technologies for building such bridges, have recognized the feasibility of this project at costs far more advantageous than maintaining the current ferries on the river. Information about this project can be consulted in the documents relating to Study 2015 via the interactive table of studies.

The studies

This site contains copies of all the accessible studies on the Tadoussac bridge. By consulting it, you will be able to understand that the Québec Ministry of Transport opposed the construction of a bridge as soon as the first conclusive studies on the relevance of replacing the ferries with a bridge were published.

1973

In 1973, the engineer T. Monti presented a bridge project prepared, among others, by the internationally renowned firm Freeman and Fox of London. These experts were responsible for the engineering of major bridges such as the bridge over the Bosphorus in Istanbul and several other major bridges elsewhere in the world. The study concluded that it would be more cost-effective for the state to build a bridge than to maintain a ferry service.

See our findings on the 1973 study

1974

In 1974, after the publication of the 1973 Monti study, which concluded that it was more economical to build a bridge than to maintain ferries, an engineer of the Ministry of Transport called into question certain parameters of this study in an attempt to discredit it.

See our findings on the 1974 study

1976

In 1976, the engineer Monti, PhD, Harvard graduate in administration, chose to present his master’s thesis in economics at McGill University partly on the Tadoussac Bridge file. He confirmed through a cost-benefit analysis that the bridge would be more economical for the Québec treasury than maintaining the ferries.

See our findings on the 1976 study

1979 (A)

In 1979, the Minister of Transport, Lucien Lessard, commissioned a study from the firm LGL to determine the cost and the optimal site for a bridge over the Saguenay in continuity with Route 138. The experts ruled out the alignments near the ferries as too costly and proposed building the bridge at the place known as La Boule, upstream of the Hydro-Québec power lines. The location offers the best advantages.

See our findings on study 1979-A

1979 (B)

The same year, senior officials of the Québec Ministry of Transport (MTQ) ordered an internal and secret study (Study 1979-B) to contradict the earlier studies, including that of 1979 (Study 1979-A). The MTQ had seen a preliminary version in 1978 of this study 1979-A, which confirmed the feasibility of a bridge at a reasonable cost at La Boule. This study 1979-B would be hidden from the Minister of Transport and would nevertheless be used to discredit the bridge project behind the scenes, and very probably contributed to the ejection of Minister Lucien Lessard from his position at Transport; he had “dared” to go against the wishes of senior officials. This is reminiscent, more than 40 years later, of the situation of Ministers Poëti, Daoust and Lessard, recently dismissed or subjected to pressure for attempting to correct the internal counter-culture at the MTQ. Study 1979-B thus asserts, contrary to the earlier studies, that the Côte-Nord had completed its economic growth with the end of construction of the Manic-Outardes hydroelectric complex, that North Shore residents generally do not use the road but rather air transport, and that ferries would be more advantageous than a bridge, although no serious analysis of the costs of the ferries was carried out. The study’s authors also biased a map presenting an alignment near the ferries to suggest that a bridge built at this location would have almost the same main span as the bridge proposed at La Boule. The alignments near the ferries had been ruled out by the expert engineers retained in Study 1979-A because they required massive investments.

See our findings on the MTQ’s study 1979-B

1986

In 1986, the architect Pierre Brisset and 2 engineering firms presented a bridge project at La Boule in which an alignment at La Boule was again considered optimal.

See our findings on the 1986 study

1999

In 1999, the MTQ undertook with the Naturam/Génivar consortium a study that took up the alignment proposed by the MTQ’s internal study of 1979 (1979B) near the ferries. The MTQ had acknowledged in study 1979A and in a 1995 update that a road to La Boule could be built without a tunnel at a reasonable cost. In 1999, the Ministry surprisingly requested a 4-lane highway over the more than 20 kilometres of access roads and added 6.5 kilometres of highway tunnels at a cost of $483M (1999), i.e. $854M (2025). It thereby sabotaged the optimal option. In addition, it presented a calculation error of $60M (1999) or $106M (2025) in the calculation of the cost of the bridge itself at La Boule. Finally, the bridge project near the ferries translates into 4 kilometres of heavy infrastructure: a 1.2 km tunnel, a bridge with a main span of 1,420 metres (220 metres more than the MTQ’s 1979B study) and a massive 950-metre viaduct.

See our findings on the 1999 study

2009

In 2009, the MTQ commissioned an impact study from the SNC-Lavalin/Génivar consortium at a cost of $2M (2001). It incorporated a cost-benefit analysis that owes more to pseudo-sorcery than to a rigorous and objective analysis of realities. The MTQ required that the tunnel of the 1999 study be eliminated, thus forcing the construction of a bridge of pharaonic dimensions and cost, more than 2 kilometres long, on a slope in order to reach the top of the mountain on the Baie-Ste-Catherine side. In doing so, it knowingly contradicted the main recommendation of the international experts who had been retained for the 1999 study. They recommended lowering the height of the deck below the 88 metres required by the MTQ in order to approach international standards and, above all, reduce the costs of the bridge. On the contrary, the MTQ and the consortium raised it to 140 metres. The costs of the project were thus inflated by $700M (2025), for a total of $1,291M (2025). Moreover, although members of the Advisory Committee of the 2009 Study, the representatives of the Société du Pont would receive more than 10 years later, in August 2016, Addendum 1 of the Impact Study, prepared in 2005, which presents an “inflated” bridge project at La Boule at a cost of $1,816M (2025), or 1.8 billion. It is noted in this addendum that the $854M (2025) of tunnels on the approach roads of the 1999 study were eliminated and replaced by kilometres of highway viaducts at a cost of several hundred million dollars.

See our findings on the 2009 study – Redo its cost-benefit analysis with our calculator

2015

In 2014, the analysts of the Société du Pont sur le Saguenay undertook a review of the La Boule project, the conclusions of which appear in Study 2015. They found that elsewhere in the world, long suspension bridges were being built on 2-lane or 4-lane roads at costs very different from those proposed by the MTQ and the consortiums. Thus, a bridge with a span similar to that proposed in the 2009 study was completed in 2013 on the Hardanger fjord in Norway at a cost of C$250M (2013); another long suspension bridge of the same dimensions as the bridge needed at La Boule (P1) will be completed at Narvik in Norway in 2017 at the tendered cost of C$250M (2013). Already in 1997, the Höga Kusten Bridge had been completed in Sweden at similar costs, and a bridge project at La Boule prepared by an MTQ engineer (Study 1998) proposed a 2-lane deck, like national Route 138. The analysts of the Société du Pont therefore considered these model bridges, which make it possible, among other things, to substantially reduce the costs of the bridge and to improve its longevity. They obtained from the international expert firm in long suspension bridge construction, COWI International, a letter confirming the feasibility of a bridge at La Boule for a cost 3 times lower than that proposed in the 2009 study.

See our more in-depth analysis

2016

Finally, we present the 2016 study because it is the only public document to which we have access that attempts to justify the construction of new ferries at Tadoussac. This justification is incoherent and incomprehensible to regular users of the Tadoussac crossing.

See our findings about the new ferries