Why is the Société du Pont sur le Saguenay getting involved with a mooring post (dolphin)?

Published on

by

in

, ,
Gildas FUNTUN

The BAPE held hearings in Tadoussac on November 8 and 9 and December 6 and 7 concerning the request of the Société des Traversiers (STQ) to install an additional mooring post (dolphin) near the lay-by wharf to moor one of the two new large ferries planned to replace the 3 current ferries.

An illogical decision

traversiers

However, no consultation took place concerning the construction of the 2 ferries (more than $200M) or the wharf works ($40M), but for this post ($1M) a BAPE was required. So the Société du Pont invited itself to the hearings to repeat what it had explained to Deputy Premier Nathalie Normandeau on March 3, 2010. Replacing the 3 current vessels, still useful for at least 10 years, with 2 larger ferries is not logical. The new boats, at peak times, will no longer be able to cross every 13 minutes but rather every 20 minutes; they will discharge platoons of 110 vehicles onto a road without passing zones to dissolve them; they will extinguish any inclination of North Shore residents to take part in Québec’s economic life other than through the mere extraction and shipping of natural resources by sea. Finally, they will increase the costs of the crossing while reducing the quality of service.

What we learned there

During the hearings we learned that the STQ did not consult the Ministry of Transport before deciding to build these boats, and that this decision was taken:

  • to provide work for the Davie shipyard in Lévis, then on the verge of bankruptcy — a bankruptcy that happened anyway.
  • to protect the jobs of the employees at the Tadoussac crossing in the long term. Almost all the participants asked that an independent analysis be conducted or that a bridge be built. It was noted that the bridge proposed by the Ministry of Transport in 2009 was overestimated by a factor of 3 and that the new ferries had been underestimated by a factor of 3 as well ($110M each instead of $33M to date). We also learned that the new ferries can be moved at any time to other STQ crossings.

What we would like to come of it

The commissioners heard the interventions and read the briefs; they listened, although their mandate is limited to the analysis of the post and not of the ferries or of alternatives to them such as a bridge. We asked them to recommend a complete analysis of the situation at the Tadoussac crossing. It would be less dangerous for road users to keep the current ferries, with 3 ferries in summer, pending the construction of the bridge.

A bridge whose construction, financing and maintenance would require only the reallocation of part of the public funds currently used to maintain the crossing.

Visit the “studies” tab to better understand why and how the Ministry of Transport and the Société des Traversiers distorted the studies for which they were responsible in 1979, 1999 and 2009.

For more detail:

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *